More like this You may also like
Haunted Fest: Official Afterparty
Oct 30
Ballet of Lights: Sleeping Beauty in a Sparkling Show
Dec 5 - Feb 27
Candlelight: The Lord of the Rings
Dec 6 - Jan 29
The Nightmare Bar
Oct 30
Candlelight: Tribute to The Beatles
Nov 8 - Jan 24
Candlelight: Queen vs. ABBA
Feb 12
Candlelight: Queen vs. ABBA
Nov 29 - Dec 26
Candlelight: Vivaldi's Four Seasons
Jan 29
Candlelight: Hip-Hop on Strings
Dec 13
Discover our top experiences
The Jury Experience - The 20 Million Dollar Heist
Nov 21 - Jan 17
Ballet of Lights: Sleeping Beauty in a Sparkling Show
Dec 5 - Feb 27
Dining in the Dark: A Unique Blindfolded Dining Experience at Rivers Club Pittsburgh
Nov 20 - Jan 22
The Jury Experience – Death by AI: Who Pays the Price?
Jan 9 - Feb 7
The Nightmare Bar
Oct 30
Dave and Boo-ster's - Pittsburgh - Homestead
Oct 31
Dave and Boo-ster's - North Hills
Oct 31
Related categories
Experience highlights The experience
A true-crime descent
Step into the shadows as the stories of Bundy, Dahmer, Gacy and Gein are brought to life through the twisted perspectives of the killers themselves.
Four killers, four cocktails
A curated tasting menu of four themed cocktails, each one paired with the case file it belongs to. Mocktails available on request.
For the morbidly curious
A meticulously crafted 90 minute evening of gripping, atmospheric live performance, built for anyone drawn to the darker side of history.
Gallery Gallery
On the day What to expect
Arrive and check in
Bring valid ID: entry is 21+ only. Arrive within the time on your ticket, up to 15 minutes before your session starts.
Take your seat
Settle into the room as your mixologists and theatrical storytellers open the first case file.
Four case files, four drinks
Each case unfolds live on stage, paired with its own cocktail, across a 90 minute descent.
Reviews Reviews
4.8/5
based on 290 reviews
JaNee J.
feb 2026
Soo good! Start to finish. Quality drinks and better performances. Would recommend
Miki C.
feb 2026
This was the most fun I've had in a very long time. The performers were excellent, the show was interesting, and the drinks were delicious! 10/10 suggest to everyone I speak to!
Sam C.
feb 2026
Outstanding!! Would like to see what the crew would've done with Auleen Wournous!
Mily L.
feb 2026
The show was amazing! I didn't know what to expect and was pleasantly surprised. Loved how each story was told from a unique POV, the drinks were fantastic. The Actor for Jeffery Dahmer was my favorite. Really hope they have more shows soon.
Meredith S.
mar 2026
My husband and I had the BEST time!!
Amanda L.
mar 2026
Great show!
Marc M.
feb 2026
We truly enjoyed the show! It was amazing that just 5 excellent actors are able to pull the whole event off, from the logistics to the terrific craft cocktails to the mesmerizing stories of monsters who lived in “plain sight.”
Jonathan E.
feb 2026
Actors were amazing. I loved the story telling and drinks were great
Lysa M.
feb 2026
Excellent show, delicious drinks!
Treasaigh C.
feb 2026
This was absolutely amazing and thrilling !!! My girlfriend loved it she is a Stephen King nut and she jumped out of her skin a Couple times. We Really enjoyed it !
In short About the experience
Serial Killer Speakeasy is a true-crime cocktail experience where four infamous American cases unfold live on stage, told through the eyes of the killers themselves. Think of your favorite true-crime podcast, with cocktails, atmosphere and a killer twist. Mocktails are available upon request.
The setlist: Ted Bundy, paired with the Friendly Stranger; Jeffrey Dahmer, paired with Apartment Two One Three; John Wayne Gacy, paired with Killer Clowns; and Ed Gein, paired with Gein's Cauldron.
About the venueCefalo's Banquet and Event Center
Address
428 Washington Ave, Carnegie, 15106
Parking
There are nearby paid parking lots.
Accessibility
The venue is ADA compliant. For deaf guests, please contact serialkiller@midnightcreative.com to arrange accommodations.
FAQs Frequently asked questions
Is this experience suitable for everyone?
What can I expect from Serial Killer Speakeasy?
How long does the experience last?
Is there an age requirement?
Do I need to print my ticket?
Are refunds allowed?
Can I transfer my tickets to another person?
Is there parking available?
Is the venue accessible?
Can the cocktails be modified for allergies?
Links of interest
Need help?
Contact Support here.