Fever exclusive
Speakeasy, Die Softly: Immersive Murder Mystery at Carmine’s ⭐ Step back in time to the roaring 20s with Speakeasy, Die Softly, a murder mystery dinner show at Carmine’s! Between flappers, mobsters, and bootleg liquor, the night begins with high spirits but quickly takes a deadly turn. Can you help crack the case before the culprit slips away?
Highlights
🍸 An award-winning dinner theatre show set inside a vintage speakeasy
🎶 Live original music from the club’s sultry songstress and her pianist
🍝 A legendary three-course family-style meal from Carmine’s Italian Restaurant
🕵️♀️ The audience is part of the story—the killer can be anyone... even you!
🏆 Awards are presented at the end of the night for ‘Best Dressed’, ‘Best Actor or Actress’, and ‘Detective of the Night’
🎁 Gift memories to someone special! Purchase a gift card for Speakeasy, Die Softly: Immersive Murder Mystery at Carmine’s here
General Info
📅 Dates and times: select your date & time directly in the ticket selector
🕒 Opening hours:
📍 Location: American Immersion Theater - Sinatra Room at Carmine's
👤 Age requirement: all ages are welcome!
♿ Accessibility: the venue is ADA compliant
❓ Please consult the FAQs of this experience here
Menu
Description
Slip into your finest glad rags and enter Lou Zar’s speakeasy, where the jazz is hot, the games are risky, and the “soda pop” flows freely. But when the feds come sniffing, and a murder is revealed, the stakes soar higher than the roulette wheel. Work alongside the detective, play your part, and keep your eyes peeled—because in this immersive experience, the killer could be anyone… even you. Speakeasy, Die Softly at Carmine’s promises laughter, suspense, and a deliciously dangerous night out you won’t soon forget. Get your tickets today!
Highlights
🍸 An award-winning dinner theatre show set inside a vintage speakeasy
🎶 Live original music from the club’s sultry songstress and her pianist
🍝 A legendary three-course family-style meal from Carmine’s Italian Restaurant
🕵️♀️ The audience is part of the story—the killer can be anyone... even you!
🏆 Awards are presented at the end of the night for ‘Best Dressed’, ‘Best Actor or Actress’, and ‘Detective of the Night’
🎁 Gift memories to someone special! Purchase a gift card for Speakeasy, Die Softly: Immersive Murder Mystery at Carmine’s here
General Info
📅 Dates and times: select your date & time directly in the ticket selector
🕒 Opening hours:
- Monday at 7:00 p.m. (doors open at 6:30 p.m.)
- Friday at 7:00 p.m. (doors open at 6:30 p.m.)
- Saturday at 4:00 p.m. (doors open at 3:30 p.m.) and 8:00 p.m. (doors open at 7:30 p.m.)
- Sunday at 5:00 p.m. (doors open at 4:30 p.m.)
📍 Location: American Immersion Theater - Sinatra Room at Carmine's
👤 Age requirement: all ages are welcome!
♿ Accessibility: the venue is ADA compliant
❓ Please consult the FAQs of this experience here
Menu
- Caesar Salad
- Penne a la vodka
- Chicken Parmigiana
- Shrimp Scampi
- Tiramisu and Cannoli
Description
Slip into your finest glad rags and enter Lou Zar’s speakeasy, where the jazz is hot, the games are risky, and the “soda pop” flows freely. But when the feds come sniffing, and a murder is revealed, the stakes soar higher than the roulette wheel. Work alongside the detective, play your part, and keep your eyes peeled—because in this immersive experience, the killer could be anyone… even you. Speakeasy, Die Softly at Carmine’s promises laughter, suspense, and a deliciously dangerous night out you won’t soon forget. Get your tickets today!
User reviews
4.6 /5
based on 88 reviews
- Loved The Experience‼️ Very Interactive. The Actors Aced Their Characters. The Food , Dont Get Me Started. AMAZING‼️
- The staff was wonderful: super-professional & very hardworking. They also did a great job of keeping all of the guests engaged. The food was fantastic. And the fact that there were no kids present, just made the experience even better.
- SUCH A FUN TIME! Good was great, overall experience was great. Most likely will go again even though we now know the whole story and secrets of the show. Still a fun and engaging experience. A great date night or group outing.
- Fun Experience
- It was fun, entertaining, full of laughs and the food was very good!
- Very enjoyable will definitely do it again
Need help?
Contact SupportSelect date and session
Ticket for 1 person, including:
- Entry to the experience
- A show
- A 3-course meal
Similar experiences
- High Line Comedy Club
Comedy Show + Mini-Golf Ticket!
Jan 16 - Nov 28From $15.60 -
The Dean NYC"Rescue Me" Singles Party: Mix and Mingle with NYC's Bravest Firefighters
New!Feb 12From $15.00 -
MehanataThe 2000s Forever Parrty by THE Y2K Parrty - Saturdays at Mehanata NYC
New!Jan 17 - Dec 26From $14.95 -
The Comic StripLate Night Comedy Showcase @ Comic Strip Live
New!Jan 16$25.00 - San Antonios
Glizzy Sundays at San Antonios - Free Hotdogs & Happy Hour NYC
New!Jan 18 - Nov 8Free $0.00 -
St. Ann & the Holy Trinity ChurchCandlelight: The Lord of the Rings
New!Apr 10 - Apr 25Limited EditionFrom $47.82 - Reykjavík
Experiences for Iceland Eclipse 2026: Tours, Day Trips & Festival Side Quests
New!Aug 3 - Aug 15From $150.00 - Brooklyn Storehouse
Brooklyn Storehouse: REZZ - As The Pendulum Swings
New!Jan 24From $57.50 -
Carmine's - Time SquareThe Grandest Princess Ball Ever!
Jan 17 - Mar 1From $42.31 -
The Cutting Room NYCBroadway Sings ABBA with a Live Orchestra
Jan 24 - Mar 26From $31.39
Discover our top experiences
-
IrondaleThe Jury Experience – Death by AI: Will New York Make Justice?
Jan 15 - Mar 28From $48.30 - The Ruby Theatre NYC
Drunk Romeo & Juliet
Jan 15 - Sep 12From $39.00 -
Kaye PlayhouseBallet of Lights: Sleeping Beauty in a Sparkling Show
Jan 23 - May 9From $39.90 -
Kaye PlayhouseBallet of Lights: Cinderella in a Sparkling Show
New!Mar 8 - Apr 4From $40.95 - ARTECHOUSE NYC
SUBMERGE
New!Jan 15 - Feb 28From $26.96 -
Sony HallDestiny's Child: Iconic Reimagined Tribute New York
New!Jan 30From $51.60 -
Carmine's - Time SquareThe Grandest Princess Ball Ever!
Jan 17 - Mar 1From $42.31 -
HEROreSOUND: An Immersive Multisensory Art Exhibition
Jan 15 - Apr 30From $18.00 -
Arte Museum New YorkARTE MUSEUM: An Immersive Media Art Exhibition
Jan 15 - Apr 30From $35.00 -
Jersey CityBubble Planet: An Immersive Experience at American Dream
Jan 15 - Mar 30From $23.90 -
New YorkMubadala New York Sail Grand Prix 2026 - Single Day Tickets
New!May 30 - May 31From $244.10 -
New YorkMubadala New York Sail Grand Prix 2026 - Weekend Tickets
New!May 30From $392.40 -
MiamiCirque du Soleil 2026: LUZIA in Miami
New!Feb 19 - Apr 25From $59.36$48.76 -
Brooklyn StorehouseBrooklyn Storehouse: Teletech New York
New!Feb 7From $74.45 -
PhiladelphiaCirque du Soleil 2026: LUZIA in Oaks
New!May 7 - Jun 7From $44.00$35.20











